This article is written by Sonu Kumari from Adamas University.
Introduction
In India, reservation has occupied a central place within the arena of Indian society as a part of the most important social action program within the world for the underprivileged. The acquisition of seats in government affairs and academic institutions, although opposed by many, was made, along with the term being extended by subsequent amendments to the Constitution of India, specifically the 23rd, 45th, 62nd, 79th, and 95th amendments.
However, booking during promotions is generally still a challenge. Established by the 77th and 85th Amendments, there have been concerns about this from the origination. These research papers seek to understand why this idea fails in its goal of ensuring economic and social equality.
History Of Reservation In Promotion
The government and courts have been at odds on the problem of reservations in promotions ever since caste quotas were expanded in 1990 to incorporate Other Backward Classes. The Constitution does not have a separate provision for bookings in promotions. However, the Supreme Court denied promotional ticket bookings as early as 1962. The Supreme Court, as a ninth justice, overturned that decision in 1992. It stopped the bookings. promotional tickets. However, it allows reservations to continue for 5 years from the date of the award. To further provide redundancy in the promotion, the government enacted the 77th Amendment to the Constitution in 1995, which included Article 16(4A) of the Constitution. Central and state governments have prepared to reserve positions for candidates from Scheduled Actors and Scheduled Tribes who are underrepresented in government positions. In 2001, the government amended Article 16(4A) to state that governments could reserve promotions for members of Scheduled Actors and Scheduled Tribes "with continuous seniority". This means that someone from the underdog promoted first will outperform a generic candidate promoted later, even if the final candidate outperforms the pre-assigned reserve candidate. promotion or not. It added Article 16(4b) to the Constitution in 2000, stating that vacancies in reserved seats would be carried over to the subsequent year and wouldn't be counted toward the 50 percent maximum on reservations in vacancies the subsequent year. In the 2006 M Nagaraj case, the court established additional criteria in addition to the three reservation conditions in promotions. It stated that reservation mustn't exceed 50% which the "creamy layer" of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes – those that are happier socially, educationally, and economically – shouldn't like reservation in promotions. The government attempted but failed to reverse this with a constitutional amendment.
Applicability At ‘ReservationIn Promotion’
When the promotion goes on, members of the Scheduled Caste and the Scheduled Tribe will be taken:
(a) A Limited Departmental Competitive Examination is used to fill positions in Group B, Group C, and Group D.
(b) capability from a Group B post to the fewest Group A posts, or within Group B, Group C, and Group D posts, is fixed by privilege.
Promotional reservations are not granted in grades where the direct recruiting component if any, exceeds 75%.
Non-Applicability Of Reservation In Promotion
Reservations are not applicable to:
(i) temporary appointments lasting less than 45 days; and
(ii) work-charged positions required for emergencies such as flood relief, accident restoration, and relief, and so on.
(iii) Promotions via preference method from one Group 'A' post to one more Group 'A' post.
(iv) Arrangements to positions in Science and Technology that are higher than the lowest rung of Group 'A.'
(v) Absorption/deputation
(vi) Cadres with a single post
Promotion By Selection
In the case of promotion by selection, vacancies in the proposed caste and the planned race must be selected from among the proposed castes/proposed races. Officials within the general review area. If there are insufficient SC/ST candidates in the general selection window, the number of vacancies may be expanded to 5 times the number of vacancies, with SC/ST candidates (excluding other candidates) from the extended selection box being counted as well. vacancies reserved for them. The following guidelines apply to filling vacancies reserved for planned castes and planned shortages in these promotions:
(i) Scheduled Team and Tribe officers are scheduled to be in the normal area of Considerations should be considered for promotion with others and evaluated based on the same facility as the others and the officers of the Scheduled Actor and the Scheduled Tribe among them, those selected on this basis can be included in the general selection list. If several SC/ST candidates are selected as elective deserving in every respect and shortlisted for their name in the number of unfilled vacancies, these candidates will be adjusted according to unfilled vacancies.
(ii) If the number of applicants from the Scheduled Actors and the Scheduled Tribe is different from those who are selected based on their merit who are adjusted for unreserved vacancies 48 is less than enough for them, needs to make a difference select applicants from the communities under consideration regardless of their merits, but those deemed suitable for promotion.
(iii) If the amount of SC/ST candidates deemed appropriate for promotion relative to reserved positions remains but the amount of positions reserved for them remains, a distinction should be created by choosing the candidates. from these communities, WHO falls at intervals the broader space of ​​consideration, despite advantage. However, those deemed fit promotion.
(iv) A brief list can then be ready, during which the names of all selected officers and generals are further as those of the regular Actors and Tribes, hierarchical in order of self-achievement and seniority consistent with the overall principles of promotion. to choose locations. However, SC/ST candidates within the broad field and people selected should be classified at an all-time low to keep up their knowledge domain position in line with their decentralisation by the DPC. This choice list should then be half-tracked to market vacancies as they arise throughout the year.
Promotion By Non-Selection
In the event of a non-selection promotion, all candidates from the scheduled Actors and scheduled Tribes lined by the list of the corresponding seniority in the overall variety of vacancies that Promotions should be created, thought of in step with their overall seniority and if they square measure not deemed unfit, they're going to be promoted. If the number of scheduled caste/ scheduled tribes candidates deemed appropriate among the actual vacancies square measure but the number of vacancies solely for them, extra candidates from scheduled Actors/Scheduled Tribes to the extent needed are going to be on the seniority list, provided they qualify and square measure deemed appropriate for the appointment.
Note 1: In request to guarantee appropriate execution of reservation of opportunities for Scheduled Castes also Scheduled Tribes in advancement, number of opportunities ought to be evaluated as precisely as conceivable. Transient opportunities ought not to be considered for this reason; nor ought any expansion be made to cover unexpected opportunities. Simultaneously, it is necessary to ensure that the quantity of openings isn't reduced. All unmistakable opportunities emerging because of death, retirement, renunciation and long Haul advancement of officeholders from one post/grade to a higher post/grade 49 ought to be considered while fixing the number of opportunities and the quantity of saved opening for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes.
Note 2: Since arrangement to Selection Grade additionally comprises advancement, the fitting requests connecting with reservation/concessions for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in advancements, would apply to the arrangement to the Selection Grade too.
Note 3: While comprising the Departmental Promotion Committee, guidelines concerning the assignment of SC/ST officials to the DPC, as given now and then, ought to be followed.
Policy Of The Government On Reservation For SCs, STs, And OBCs
With open competition, SCS STS and OBC reservations for adopting directly in all India are given at a rate of 15%, 7.5%, and 27%, respectively. By adopting directly in all India other than Open Competition, SC-ST and OBC reservation is 16.66% 7.5%, 25.84%. In the case of direct Recruit EM group C and D-POST to attract areas or regional candidates, the proportion of spare FERS SC / STS is generally focused on the percentage of SC-population. Each column / UTS for OBC is determined by the ratio of the percentage of the Decongested State / UT, and SCST test reservation is determined again with the reservation within the scope of OBC within the limit of 50%. increase. 27% remain.
Promotional reservations SC, STC’s and of OBCs and D at 7.5%, or 7.5% Rate Promotion Rate Estimated Value A Less 18 There is a promotion reservation that chooses Group A's contribution to the ultimate content of 30 rupees (open scale), but the Planned representative, the advanced person is Zone consideration for promotion. This list applies that the number of open places to be selected is included in this list, so it cannot be recognized.
There Is No Reservation In Case Of Promotion Within Group A
SC and ST reservations are available at all levels related to non-selective promotions. For promotion by choice, it will be booked up to the lowest level in Group A. There are no reservations for promotion by choice within Group A, but the maximum salary is 18.30 rupees or less at the established rates for Scheduled Caste officers. A designated tribe that is sensitive enough in the fare avoidance zone to stay within the number of vacant seats included in the candidate list, unless deemed unsuitable for promotion. Great care is taken to ensure that SE / ST officers are promoted to such senior Khan, even if they do not meet the criteria set for the Supreme Court's general candidates.
Indra Sawhney’s case declared pressure conditions. However, to maintain pressure conditions, Article 77 of the Constitution was amended, including Article 4 of the Constitution (4A), allowing the state to continue the promotion. The explanation of the purpose and reason of the constitution (Eight-Sixth Amendment) until the establishment of the constitution (77-Amendment Act) stated that the purpose was to continue the dispersion that existed at that time. Before the Supreme Court's decision in Indra Sawhney’s case, as of August 13, 1997, issued following Group A position O.M. Article 16 (4A), carriage by choice of Group "A" entities. The existing exemption that did not allow reservations was restored.
SC Refuses To Lay Down Yardstick For Granting Reservation Promotion To SCs/STs
On Friday, the Supreme Court provided quantifiable data on the inadequacy of roster castes and scheduled (ST) employee representatives in government work before the state made reservations for promotion. Said it needs to be collected. The court rejected the ruling on quantifying the insufficiency of representatives of promotion reservations, alleging that the government was calling. The SC further stated that no new standards could be set after the Constitutional Court's decision. The Supreme Court has given a wide range of parameters regarding reservations for the promotion of SC and ST staff. Determine the effectiveness of the centre and various state government guidelines for booking carriage for these parameters. Meanwhile, the court said it would call the Centre’s 1997 vehicle reservation bureau's memorandum of validity. The Delhi High Court overturned it in 2017, and since then there has been no reservation for the promotion of central services. The centre had previously told banks that after about 75 years of independence, it is true that the relevant STs and SCs have not reached the same level of benefits as forwarding grades. The Supreme Court withheld the verdict of October 26, 2021.
Conclusion
Therefore, it's far now mounted regulation that if country seeks to offer reservation to contributors of SCs and STs, it has to accumulate quantifiable records vis-a-vis illustration of SCs and STs in a specific cadre of a carrier and it has to shape an opinion approximately inadequacy of illustration primarily based totally on that records. Further, however hard it'd be, the country additionally has to check the impact of reservation on the performance in administration. It is best at the fulfilment of those criteria, the country can justify its motion of supplying reservations in promotions.
Your article left a lasting impression on me and I wanted to express my sincere appreciation for your insights analysis and eloquent writing
Your article was a delightful read and I wanted to thank you for the valuable information
Your article was incredible insightful and well written thank you for sharing your expertise in this topic
Your article truly resonated with me offering valuable insights that i deeply appreciate